iCharts Discussions

[chandrujimrc]

Dear friends,


I would like to discuss about mkt manipulation in this thread.Seniors comment most welcome.First up all I would like to know,


.Is it possible to controll the mkt by a person who is having money power like Ambanis.If yes how,if not why?The bulls who were able to bring the mkt from 5950 yesterday low to 5200 today"s high but unable to cross 5200,why and where they gone, likewise bears who were able to brought down from 5500 to 4950 but not below 4950 why and where they gone.Thirdly after the election result in 2009 how the mkt went to freeze lvl with very very low turnover.Dear friends serious comments welcome.

chandru.

[chandrujimrc]

Manipulation in the form of consolidation is going on.



chandru.

[mania]

These kind of topics are debatable and just for time pass. My suggestion do not try to find answer for the questions, which no one have answers. If anyone knew the answers, they would n't be here in this forum....

All TV guys,analyst so called experts will try to market themselves and talk only about their success trades... not the failed trades... I have never seen any one showing the trade log to prove their expertise... It's easy to be analyst than a trader... bcaz trader is the one goes through emotions and get lost in the emotions...

Only 5% of people are making money in the market from the remaining 95%..So, Have a trading plan, follow the rules, apply money management, which is the biggest hurdle for me alteast... you will win. Remember trading is a serious business and it is an art , not a science....

Happy Trading...
my 2 cents..

[chandrujimrc]

Dear mania,

Thanks fot your comment.Let us wait,some one will have answer.


chandru.

[chandrujimrc]

Dear friends,

Be carefull mkt at manipulation spot.



chandru.

[chandrujimrc]

where was the bull at 5180?.The same bull has turned as bear.

chandru.

[vinay28]

Chandru, you are right in your views but the guys who are doing it are not going to tell us what they are doing.

[chandrujimrc]

Hi vinay, yes you are correct.They won"t tell us because their style of trading is entirely different from ours.They will do in borh the sides simultaneously but in dttfferent quantity at different lvls.So that they dont bother about the bull rally or bear rally,what ever it is.

chandru.

[amitsaraf21]

markets may be manipulated for brief period and that too in some specific areas. Markets are too big to be controlled for long.

Also people think that manipulation is way to make money and it is bcoz of manipulators an average person loses money in markets.


It is the game of speculation which is very difficult and manipulation is not the way to make money in the markets.

Smart players soon realise that there are much easier ways than manipulation to make consistent money out of the markets.

[chiragbvyas]

meaningless thread. there could be much more questions asked but will never get correct or meaningful answers. so better try to learn T A and dont waste your time in activities like this.

[chandrujimrc]

Dear chiragbvyas,


If you have answer for the questions raised by me you reply,otherwise leave it no problem.Any how thanls for your comments.

chandru.

[sartaj]

Hi,
It is just a illusion that the market(Nifty) can be manipulated. There are 100's of different rich people having different trading idea. Hence the bull bear fight. It is only possible to manipulate small scrips but not largecaps. If this people would have been able to manipulate the markets then we would have had many more R. Jhunjhunwala. But it is only one. So its better not to think about manipulation. My just one advise if you are a trader is in this volatile times trade on a shorter time frame eg. if u traded on a 4 hour chart then trade on 1 hour chart or 30 min chart.

Take care

[chrome]

hi chandruji,

i agree, only 5% of market players constitute 95% of market ups n downs.......volume does matter..and matters a lot....simple logic of demand supply and it applies to our beloved market too !!

[casper]