iCharts Discussions

[kamal.icharts]

Dear Member,

We sincerely apologize for the typing mistake and missing out the message in this regard. The Challenge is always for the expiry of Nifty and this also will be for this month expiry i.e. 30th Oct 2014.

All entries will be matched with today closing and the result will be declared accordingly.

We once again apologize for the mistake and will ensure to be careful in future.

Thanks for pointing out my mistake.

Regards

Kamal

[nithesh_n]

Who is the Winner ?

[kaydee11]

Dear Kamal

This is not fair on your part to change the rules after the completion of the challenge. Certainly not. It will be injustice to the participants.

For best of justice (because the error is on your side) you should give 2 rewards this month, one for the NIFTY expiry and one for 31.10.14 close as stipulated this time.

Hope you will not do injustice and better sense will prevail,

Thanks

[kamal.icharts]

Dear Member,

We understand it was mistake at my end and to rectify it, your suggestion will be accepted. We will declare 2 winners - One whose entry is close to closing of 30th Oct 2014 and the other of 31st Oct 2014.

Regards

Kamal

[kaydee11]

[pkholla]

Kamal: To avoid controversy in future, let us all understand clearly that the Kontest refers to NF value AT THE EXPIRY OF THE MONTH'S NF CYCLE

eg for Nov 2014 = NF value at end of day's play on 27th Nov 2014

Kamal, please henceforth only give the deadline before which eligible entries should be posted in the Kontest!

Thank you, Prakash Holla

[kaydee11]

Kamal Sir

IMO, the contest should be for monthly closing and not for expiry closing.

As this is the value that one can calculate/derive using charts, patterns and some intelligence. While the expiry closing is pure guess and has no relevance to any type of analysis etc Moreover the closing value is based on the positions of big gamers or operators or whatever you name them

[nithesh_n]

Ok Thanks Kamal... Who is the two winners then ?

[kamal.icharts]

CONGRATULATIONS to users ajit602 and kaydee11 for being the WINNERS of the FUTURE NIFTY CHALLENGE for OCT 2014.

NIFTY FUTURE closed at 8166.6 on 30th Oct 2014. Username ajit602 entry was 8142, which was the closest.

NIFTY FUTURE closed at 8352.7 on 31st Oct 2014. Username kaydee11 entry was 8250, which was the closest.

We have started your PLATINUM subscription and an email has been forwarded regarding this.

Regards

Kamal

[kaydee11]

Thanks

[amitagg]

[nithesh_n]

This is really unfair Kamal... My entry was 8180 only 13 point difference from Nifty Future on 30th October... But you gave award for 8142 which is 25 point difference

[nithesh_n]

8180 - 8166 = 14...
8166 - 8142 = 24...

My entry is closer...

[kamal.icharts]

Dear Nitin,

I sincerely apologize for the second blunder made for this challenge

Yes your entry is the closest one and hence we have allocated 1 month subscription to you. We have mailed your regarding this.

CONGRATULATIONS to user nithesh_n for being the WINNER of the FUTURE NIFTY CHALLENGE for OCT 2014.

NIFTY FUTURE closed at 8166.6 on 30th Oct 2014. Username nithesh_n entry was 8180, which was the closest.

Due to the error from my side, the subscription of ajit602 will be continued; as declared earlier.

Regards

Kamal

PS : I sincerely apologize for the mistakes made during this Challenge.

[nithesh_n]

Thanks a lot...