iCharts Discussions

[doji]

Good thing that this thread was stopped. It was blatant self-promotion with future business motive. There was no value addition to the Forum. When members requested posting of relevant charts, it was not done citing one reason or the other. Sharing of knowledge was not the objective of this thread.

Won't you agree SH?

Sorry if you feel hurt, but I always speak my mind and don't mince words.

[Stockhunter]

[sjjhala]

Dear SH,

A) When I read doji's message, I simply chose to ignore it. It is obvious that he does not know you, or for that matter, many people at icharts community.

B) I am impressed with the maturity shown by you in your reply. I respect you even more.

C) Finally, just as Jesus, let us all forgive the transgressions of everyone else as they do not know what they do (smiling).

Carry on SH. You have really no idea how much you have helped people earn money.

[RAKA]

Yeah SH do carry on your work . Though I dont follow your messages in the SB but I do read the messages of all the participants just to avoid boredom during trading hours. By reading your messages I cound understand that you know many new logical things that most of the traders are deprieved of. So using your knowledge if you can help others, it is the best thing Good Lord can ask you to do. And beleive me, by sharing knowledge you will improve your own personal skills.
So avoid comments and carry on your good work.
Cheers

[NORBE_1958]

Please donot disturb your mind as it is said there are so many spectators in a stadium seeing Sachin play ,if he scores they praise him and if he doesnot score they even go to the extend to teach him how to play. A so call method of the MR PERFECT always.

I appreciate your intentions , it was for the good of all, but there are days it turns bad,thats a only a ruf patch ,everyone has them Dont bother at all, You are a jewel that will shine always in my view.

[doji]

RAKA wrote

"And beleive me, by sharing knowledge you will improve your own personal skills."

[Stockhunter]

[muthuswamy82]

dear sir,
why did u stop writing ? your calls were not so bad. you can write for all those who follow.
even u can define the capital. one day u have traded 5 calls on nifty n stocks together which will need a minimum capital of 5 lakhs.
would prefer to see u giving calls and percentage gains from a capital of around one lakh.

[VenkatRam]

Dear SH Sir,

This is my first post after seeing & reading what all is going on for the last 3-4 months. You initially started with Donchain Channel & were "gungoo" abt it for sometimes. Later started talking about pivotes (daily/ monthly/ yearly). Then you became "NEO" and had claimed to crack the market logic.

After that you started giving one magic number before market open & later 2...3 & now 5 (though they are based on classical pivotes). You yourself say that you hedge NF with options but when someone else does it, you say its difficult to understand why people do so & why not rather buy options. Its very surprsingly.

In SB you say you have shorted NF & later you say you are long. You have started giving calls in competition to paid rooms & your target is 10 points and SL is more than 25. More so even you didnt update 80 points loss in your ledger last week.

You yourself are trying to break SB rules by smartly posting blog google hints. We all know SB is a place just to share our ideas & not to give calls or promote our blogs. Now when nothing seems to be working you started another "315" system.

Every one can clearly see what you are trying to achieve here. This is public forums and people are not silly that they dnt understand what you want to achieve here.

Would appreciate if you please restrain from doing all this and do something productive. I second doji sir's response and glad that you are stopping writings in forums & would not talk stock market in SB (as you said yesterday)

All the best.

Thanks
VR

[Stockhunter]

Dear Mr VenkatRam (or whoever it is using a dummy name),


Your ID says you joined Icharts today on 4th April, so funny that you have been watching what is going on for last 3-4 months.

Atleast be a man and comment using your existing ID.. its very easy to create a fake mail ID, then register on icharts using that mail ID and post comments under a fake name. Who knows you might be doji himself posting under different names.

But still,whoever you are, I dont know what you have against me talking about donchain channels, pivot points or my strategy 315. I also talk about SMA channels, RSEX and many other things .. can't i talk about them? Many people here talk about many things.. strange you are picking on me


and why r u against magic numbers.. there so many many such chain of numbers like classical, non classical, Camarilla, fibo etc etc .. you want to curse their inventors too

And yes 'Neo' was just for fun.... but no denying I have cracked the logic.. any problems my dear friend with that? or is it just jealousy?

options.. mm .. buy NF and buy a puts as well at the same time sounds crazy to me... i hedge my NF with options only overnight.. again thats my strategy .. you should chill

Mr VenkatRam (or whoever that is) .. let me remind you that i never hinted how to google my blog.. some of the SB fellow traders themselves did that when i declined to provide my URL in SB ... you again seem to have selective amnesia.

and the last thing which you said.. 'Every one can clearly see what you are trying to achieve here ' ... I see most of the people wanting me to continue my posts ... appreciating me for sharing my knowledge.. thats what i wanted to achieve ... some friends... From where i stand and see.. I have more friends in SB than probably you... thats becuase i have done something 'productive' as you said for my fellow ichartians.

Let me ask you my friend.. what have you done to share knowledge till now? Why did you need to create a fake ID to post this ..? Look inside my friend.. maybe you will get an answer.

In the end.. i forgive you and others who might have antagonism againt me.. for criticism makes me stronger.

and by the way, it was my decision to stop this thread, my decision to stop talking about markets in SB ... but if you get some selfish pleasure from it.. so be it.

BE happy my friend...

Cheers
SH

[muthuswamy82]

Sad to hear that you wont write anymore.
anyways let me know how to join your blog. how can i get my IP? do i have to write to the internet company for an IP ?
and sharing that is legal ?
please let me know asap

[doji]

Dear SH,

I would have simply laughed off your hint that the ID Venkatram belongs to me and would have gone on to do better things. But I'm posting this to help you. In this day and age, it's not at all impossible to find the geographical locations of members through their IPs . So go ahead and use your good offices to find out (from Ichart staff )the locations from where these two posts (mine and venkatram's) originated.

Let me admit that me and my family had a good laugh at your innuendo that I need a fake ID to express my views about you.

[Stockhunter]

[Ramoney]

Dear SH,
I was also following your comments in SB. But in recent days when i actually entered in trade i burnt my fingers. in last 15 days if u see your comments u would understand ur mistakes.Any how u r not responsible and it is left out to the SB users to decide on their own. But still I appreciate ur work in SB and your findings in RSEX. So u r welcome back and give valid comments cautiously which will help the new traders who r new to technicals and blindly go on with comments passed on the SB by seniors like you.
Regards,
Ramoney

[doji]

Dear friend SH,

On seeing Ramoney's post , I was reminded of this English proverb:

" Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime"

If you have the time and INCLINATION please 'feed' the newbies here in Icharts forum 'for a lifetime'.

I wish you all the very best in markets and life.